·
3 minute read
The Connection
The average tenure of Chief Marketing Officers has hit a concerning low of 40 months according to Spencer Stuart's latest CMO tenure analysis. While factors like economic uncertainty and shifting digital landscapes contribute to this decline, there's a hidden culprit that often goes unnoticed: poor data quality.
According to Gartner's Data Quality Market Survey, poor data quality costs organizations an average of $12.9 million annually. For marketing leaders, this translates into missed opportunities, wasted budgets, and ultimately, shorter tenures. The problem isn't just about having bad data – it's about not knowing your data is bad until it's too late.
Signs Your Data Quality Is Putting Your Job at Risk
Campaign results that consistently underperform despite increased spending
When you keep pumping more budget into campaigns but see diminishing returns, it often indicates underlying data problems. This typically manifests as targeting the wrong audiences or making decisions based on incorrect performance metrics, leading to inefficient spending that fails to drive meaningful results.
Inability to accurately report marketing's contribution to pipeline
If you struggle to draw clear lines between marketing activities and revenue generation, your attribution data likely has gaps or inconsistencies. This makes it impossible to prove marketing's value to the organization and often results in budget cuts since you can't demonstrate clear ROI.
High email bounce rates and poor deliverability
When your contact database is filled with outdated, incorrect, or improperly formatted email addresses, it leads to high bounce rates and potential blacklisting by email providers. This not only wastes resources but can permanently damage your sender reputation and ability to reach legitimate contacts.
Sales team complaints about lead quality
When sales consistently reports that marketing-generated leads are unqualified or don't match ideal customer profiles, it usually points to problems with data collection or lead scoring systems. This creates friction between departments and undermines marketing's credibility within the organization.
Difficulty proving ROI on marketing investments
If you can't confidently tie marketing spending to business outcomes, it often stems from disconnected data systems or inconsistent tracking mechanisms. This makes it nearly impossible to justify marketing budgets during financial reviews and puts your position at risk during cost-cutting initiatives.
HubSpot's State of Marketing Report shows that 27% of business leaders aren't sure if their data is clean enough for effective segmentation. This uncertainty leads to poor decision-making and eroded trust from executive leadership.
We recommend initiating a full review of all marketing data as you onboard in a new organization. Do not take it for granted that the data, systems, and teams you inherit will know how to manage data quality issues.
The Solution Starts With Acknowledging the Problem
Auditing your current data quality metrics
Regular data audits serve as your organization's early warning system, combining monthly health checks with quarterly field analysis to catch issues before they become critical problems. Data completeness scoring and duplicate detection work together to maintain database integrity, while third-party verification ensures accuracy.
Implementing strict data governance policies
Establish clear rules and processes for how data enters your systems, who can modify it, and what standards must be maintained. This involves creating detailed documentation of data handling procedures, setting up validation rules to prevent bad data from entering your systems, and ensuring all team members understand their role in maintaining data quality. Regular training sessions should reinforce these policies.
Investing in proper data enrichment tools
Select and implement tools that can automatically validate, clean, and enhance your marketing data. These tools should be able to verify contact information, append missing fields, standardize formats, and identify duplicate records. The key is choosing solutions that integrate well with your existing tech stack while providing the specific enrichment capabilities your organization needs. We are big fans of Apollo.io for this.
Creating regular data cleanup processes
Develop systematic procedures for ongoing data maintenance, including scheduled reviews, automated cleaning routines, and regular validation checks. This means setting up automated workflows to flag potential issues, establishing regular intervals for manual reviews, and creating clear processes for handling exceptions and edge cases.
Establishing clear ownership of data quality
Designate specific individuals or teams responsible for maintaining data quality standards across different systems and processes. This includes defining roles and responsibilities, creating accountability measures, and ensuring there's a clear escalation path for addressing data quality issues when they arise. Regular reporting on data quality metrics should be part of this ownership structure.
Marketing leaders who prioritize data quality are three times more likely to report successful campaign outcomes according to Forrester's B2B Marketing Report. Don't let poor data quality cut your tenure short.
More Questions?
Need help assessing your marketing data quality? Schedule a consultation to discover how we can help support your marketing leadership position.
Related Reading: The True Cost of Bad Data: Beyond the 1-10-100 Rule
